The Foolishness of Relying on Social-Media Numbers

A little yarn about just looking at specious statistics.
Aug | 31 | 2015

Aug | 31 | 2015


Some people equate the number of followers on different social networks with importance and influence. (Hell, they call it Klout for a reason, right?)

And this is often a mistake.

In a very real sense, the Internet has changed nothing. People will always try to game the system, whether that’s with Twitter followers, Spotify listens, or Facebook likes. Churchill’s quote above on democracy is equally apropos to capitalism. It simultaneously represents both the best and worst that we can do. The fleas come with the dog.

As I’ll explain below, relying on these numbers is often both foolish and even destructive.

A Little Yarn

I know a guy who bills himself as an “influencer”, a term that I despise. (It implies that influence is a binary, not a continuum. Everyone has some degree of influence.)

Let’s call him Terry here, a nod to Ocean’s Eleven. Terry’s bona fides look good on a superficial level. He sports more than 50,000 Twitter followers and a Klout score north of 70. Primarily because of this, a Fortune 50 company a while back paid him to attend a major event. It was easy money: Terry only had sit on a panel and blog and tweet a few musings about the conference.

Did things go according to plan? Of course not.

It turns out that Terry likes drama and caused quite the ruckus. He got into it with a few others on the panel and then took his rant to Twitter, packing an extraordinary amount of vitriol into 140 or fewer characters. He expressed his displeasure at being a “puppet” for tech companies and, stuffing salt in the wound, made sure to include the event’s hashtag.

Did I mention that he was paid to attend this event?

The point of this little yarn is that social-media numbers often tell at best an incomplete story. More Twitter followers doesn’t mean a hill of beans.

A Better Social-Media Strategy

For my part, I prefer that a relatively small but growing number of sentient human beings follow me, not a mix of people, bots, and spam accounts. To this end, I recently audited my account. Here’s what I found:

View post on

Not bad. Ninety-five percent of my followers are real. In the past, I have used tools like ManageFlitter to purge undesirable accounts from my official numbers.

Simon Says

For my money, quality trumps quantity every time. Period. Poseurs are usually exposed eventually.


What say you?

Receive my musings, news, and rants in your inbox as soon as they publish.


Blog E Social Media E The Foolishness of Relying on Social-Media Numbers

Related Posts

Forces Are Colliding

In a nutshell, my latest book examines powerful forces that are reshaping the workplace. As I researched them and wrote the book's manuscript, the fascinating interrelationships between and among these forces began to manifest themselves. Examples abound, but today...

Book Review: Wonder Boy

In 2011, I moved from NJ to Vegas. It didn't take long for me to hook up with the Vegas tech scene and the Downtown Project. Over the course of my five years in Sin City, I attended events, spoke at Zappos's HQ a few times, met plenty of smart cookies, and learned a...

Publication of The Nine

am pleased to announce the publication of The Nine: The Tectonic Forces Reshaping the Workplace. I believe that it's my best work to date. Check out the trailer, praise, and a few excerpts on the book's main page. As of now, the paperback and...


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *