Probably the world's leading independent expert

on workplace collaboration & technology 🇺🇦

My Social Media Experiment

Fed up with my recurrent VOIP problems, I have decided to take Comcast to task.
Dec | 12 | 2009

Dec | 12 | 2009

Fed up with my recurrent VOIP and Internet problems, I have decided to take Comcast to task. Long lauded for its proactive approach to using social media in a customer relations’ context, Comcast has a Twitter account created specifically for dealing with unhappy customers.

Count me in.

8:04 am: Initial Tweet

Around 8 am on Saturday morning, after a predictably unsuccessful call to customer relations, I decided to tweet my way to satisfaction–or at least try.


And I sent them an email to boot:


I gave them my number.  Really.  Truly.

A few minutes later, I decided to go all in and put this on Facebook as well:


To paraphrase Otter from Animal House, “I put it to you, Comcast.” Let’s see if you’re up to the challenge.  Game on.

I’ll be updating this post and tweeting its progress.  Stay tuned …

11:01 am Update: Test for Echo?


Well, I have my first comment on my blog, but not from Comcast.

Three hours and nary an email or direct Twitter message.  What gives?  How does Comcast at least not have an autoresponder on this email address? Maybe I should go “old school” and get a land line?

I’m adding a poll as well to make this as interactive as possible.

[polldaddy poll=2376868]

12:15 pm: Possible Success?

I had placed a call with Comcast at 7 am, hoping to get someone to come to my home today. Monday was the earliest possible day, the rep told me.  I asked if he could call me should that changed and he promised a call back within an hour.

Roughly five hours later (not bad by Comcast standards), I receive voice mail on my cell phone (remember, that’s the only option at this point).  They’re coming between 3 pm and 5 pm. Of course, this means that they’re coming between 3 pm and whenever.

I sincerely doubt that anyone managing either the Comcast Cares Twitter account or the related inbox called the local rep. Is it possible? Sure …why not?

At this point, I just want to see if my Tweets or email is acknowledged. So, in a way, the point of my experiment has changed from its original intention: fixing the problem. I’m now intent on seeing if anyone merely listens.


Unrealistic Expectations?

In no particular order, I have a bunch of questions:

  • Should I have actually expected a response from @comcastcares?
  • Should I have lowered the bar since it’s a Saturday?
  • Does our Twitter-based universe mean that no response in a four  hour window is the equivalent of being blown off?
  • Why have a customer service-oriented Twitter account set up if you’re not going to respond?

1:26 pm: The Plot Thickens and a Social Media Noir

I checked my Twitter followers to find that I have been acknowledged on some level (although this may have been an “autofollow”):


I can’t decide if this is an autoresponse or Frank’s team:

Frank Eliason | Philadelphia, PA Following

Here is a first! I am signing off for a vacation. I will return 12/21. My team will be here or email [email protected]  about 22 hours ago

Interesting …  Perhaps I’ll get tired of this soon but, in between errands, this isn’t a bad way to pass a cold Saturday here in New Jersey.

This is getting to be quite the social media noir.

2:23 pm: The verdict is in …or so I thought

I’ve decided that six hours is plenty of time for at least some type of acknowledgment. I am pulling the plug on my Comcast Social Media Experiment. Maybe my next one won’t be with Comcast. Some management type once said, “Listen to your customers or someone else will.”

Shame on you, @comcastcares.  I can only assume that no one’s minding the store or too many people are tweeting you about poor service.

2:50 pm: Contact on the Twitter front

Wow …  My tweets have found their mark after all.


The irony is that my sporadic Internet connection makes receiving  these in real time tough.  Oh yeah, I have an email alert and a CrackBerry.  I know that Frank went on vacation but I sure hope that his vacation didn’t mean that the whole team wouldn’t respond.


Comcast has 600,000 VOIP users in NJ, according to their rep, and I don’t see how one guy could handle NJ, much less the entire Comcast customer base.

3:32 pm: The phone rings …

Someone checked an email or tweet. Someone from some executive office somewhere in the Comcast Kingdom called me to advise that someone will, in fact be here by 5 pm.  I only wish that it didn’t take over seven hours to contact me.

5:56 pm: Lessons learned

I have learned the following from this experiment:

  • At least with respect to Comcast, to resolve a problem, it still appears necessary to work multiple channels:
    • Twitter
    • Email
    • Phone
  • Comcast’s social media (i.e., Twitter) strategy can use some fine-tuning
  • Modems should come with surge protectors

Want these posts to arrive in your inbox?

Receive my musings, news, and rants in your inbox as soon as they publish.


Blog E Social Media E My Social Media Experiment

Related Posts


  1. Mike West

    Phil, “I don’t understand why it takes you three days to send someone out to fix my phone an internet”

    Comcasts reply, “we don’t understand why it takes you 3 YEARS to finally bring this up”

    Which may be precisely the answer.

  2. Jim Harris

    Phil called me today from his Comcast phone line. The connection was filled with static, here’s what I heard:

    Comcast is such a [VOIP Static] company. I mean, I have been waiting for [VOIP Static] five [VOIP Static] hours for these [VOIP Static] people to get back to me!

    Comcast [VOIP Static] Cares? Well, I’ll you what [VOIP Static] Comcast doesn’t [VOIP Static] care about – Phil [VOIP Static] Simon – not one [VOIP Static] bit, that’s for [VOIP Static] sure!

    I don’t know what words I missed amongst all that static, I’m sure they weren’t important – just like how keeping Phil as a customer isn’t [VOIP Static] important to [VOIP Static] Comcast!

  3. philsimon

    Actually, the phone was fine. I just randomly stop talking every few words. 🙂


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *